Someone on a foraging walk holds up a leaf and asks whether it is safe to eat. They’ve asked the teacher and the teacher says yes. The leaf goes into their mouth and the point of learning has passed and nobody looks at that leaf again.
On the surface nothing has gone wrong. The answer was correct and the person is fine. The plant was edible but it’s when they go home that the problem happens because they still know nothing. The teacher has merely spoon-fed them: “Can I do this? Yes you can, student.”
The next time they meet the same plant in a lane and the teacher is not beside them, they are no further on in their learning journey than before they took the course. A lot of plant teaching works like this. Someone with a book or a reputation tells you what a plant is and what it is good for and so you write it down. The facts pile up and they feel like knowledge. Yet they are still someone else’s and as students we have simply borrowed them.
Every time you have questions and answers or questions arise, you have to go back to the person whose words you have written down verbatim. True learning comes when you take the words of the teacher and test them in the fire of real life.
That means the teacher is merely a starting point. They’re not the end game. The end game is that you become your own authority and your own teacher. The only way you can do that is to really engage with the plants around you.
The next time you’re on a course and you ask the guide, the instructor, “Is this plant edible?” and they say yes, ask them to take you deeper into the experience. Ask them, “Why and how do I know this plant is edible? What are the discerning features?” Ask them to teach at a deeper level than merely a talking head, a yes/no educationalist.
As I say in The Way of Domei, ‘knowledge is not knowing’. My approach to teaching plants is for you to develop your own deep knowing rather than being able to spin facts and figures that you’ve read in books or heard online. And that knowing, that understanding: the chances are you won’t find it in the books but the books are the starting point of discovery, of the journey.
The teacher who hands you answers but never shows you how to question them has not really taught you. They’ve made you dependent on them and dependence is not something you want to carry into a wood on your own.
Being able to test what you have heard against what you can see, smell, and taste is not where ecological literacy ends. It’s simply the beginning and the plant journey, this walk down the green path, everything moving forwards is built on it.
I ask you, where in your own learning are you still dependent on someone else’s eyes more than your own.